What Is Linear Phase EQ? The Complete Guide

In the world of audio processing, the use of linear phase EQs has become increasingly popular among mixing and mastering engineers. Unlike traditional equalizers that can introduce phase shifts and distortions, linear phase EQ maintains a consistent phase response across all frequencies. This is achieved by delaying the audio signal, allowing for precise control over the harmonic spectrum without affecting the original tonal balance.

Why is this important? The significance of linear phase EQ lies in its capability to achieve a more transparent sound than standard EQs. This makes it particularly valuable in mixing and mastering applications where clarity and definition are paramount.

By reading this article, you will gain a comprehensive understanding of what linear phase EQ is, how it works, its key features and benefits, practical applications in mixing and mastering, and how it compares to standard equalizers.

Understanding Linear Phase EQ

Linear phase EQ is designed to preserve the phase relationship of audio signals while making frequency adjustments. It achieves this through advanced digital processing techniques that differ significantly from traditional equalizers.

How Linear Phase EQ Works

Linear phase EQ applies a consistent phase shift across all frequencies, ensuring that the original phase relationships within the audio signal remain intact. Here’s how it works:

1. Phase Preservation: Unlike traditional equalizers, which often introduce non-linear phase shifts, linear phase EQ maintains a steady phase response. This means that all frequency components of the audio signal are delayed by the same amount, preserving the timing and coherence of the original sound.
2. Latency Considerations: The process of maintaining consistent phase relationships necessitates a delay in the audio signal. This inherent latency is a critical aspect to consider, especially in real-time applications like live sound mixing where immediate feedback is essential.

Key Features, Benefits, & Cons of Linear Phase EQ

Filter Types in Linear Phase Equalizers

Different filter types are available within popular linear phase equalizers, each designed to address specific audio needs:

• Low-Pass Filters: These filters allow frequencies below a certain cutoff point to pass while attenuating higher frequencies. Ideal for removing high-frequency noise.
• High-Pass Filters: These filters work oppositely, allowing frequencies above a certain cutoff point to pass while attenuating lower frequencies. Useful for eliminating low-end rumble.
• Band-Pass Filters: These filters allow a specified range of frequencies to pass while attenuating frequencies outside this range. Perfect for isolating specific frequency bands.
• Notch Filters: Designed to attenuate a narrow band of frequencies while leaving other frequencies largely unaffected. Often used for removing problematic resonances or hums.

Improved Frequency Response Control

Linear phase EQs provide unparalleled control over frequency response. Unlike traditional equalizers that may introduce phase shifts, they maintains a consistent phase response across all frequencies. This ensures that any adjustments made do not alter the original tonal balance of your audio signal, which is essential when applying Q values in your EQ settings. The result is a more transparent sound, preserving the integrity of the source material.

Pre-ringing Issues

What is Pre-Ringing?

Pre-ringing is an artifact that occurs when using linear phase equalizers (EQs). It manifests as a subtle echo or “ringing” sound that precedes the main transient of an audio signal. This effect is particularly noticeable on sounds with sharp transients, such as drums, plucked strings, or other percussive elements. The pre-ringing can soften these transients, leading to a loss of clarity and impact in the audio, which can be undesirable, especially in genres like electronic dance music (EDM) or hip-hop, where transient precision is crucial.

How Do Linear Phase EQs Introduce Pre-Ringing?

Linear phase EQs maintain the phase relationships across all frequencies in a signal, ensuring that no phase shifts occur as you adjust different frequency bands. This is achieved through a process known as finite impulse response (FIR) filtering, which requires the EQ to analyze the audio in both forward and reverse directions. While this method effectively eliminates phase distortion, it also introduces a delay in the signal processing, leading to the creation of pre-ringing artifacts.

Pre-ringing occurs because the EQ attempts to compensate for phase shifts by delaying the entire signal, which results in a brief, unintended echo before the main sound. This artifact is more pronounced at lower frequencies and when using high Q (narrow bandwidth) settings with significant gain adjustments.

How to Minimize Pre-Ringing

1. Use Minimum Phase EQ When Possible: If phase accuracy is not critical for your project, consider using a minimum phase EQ instead. Minimum phase EQs do not produce pre-ringing because they do not attempt to preserve phase relationships in the same way as linear phase EQs.

2. Lower the Q Value: Reducing the Q value (broadening the bandwidth) of your EQ cuts can help minimize the severity of pre-ringing. Wider bandwidths result in less pronounced pre-ringing artifacts, making the effect less noticeable.

3. Adjust the EQ Resolution Settings: Many linear phase EQs, such as those from FabFilter or iZotope, allow you to adjust the resolution or quality settings. Lowering the resolution can reduce the pre-ringing effect, though this might also compromise the precision of the EQ.

4. Apply EQ Sparingly: Use linear phase EQs only when necessary, such as in situations where phase coherence is critical (e.g., mastering or parallel processing). For general tone shaping, a minimum phase EQ may be more appropriate and less prone to introducing unwanted artifacts.

5. Experiment with Mixed-Phase Modes: Some modern EQ plugins offer mixed-phase modes, which blend characteristics of both linear and minimum phase processing. These modes can provide a good balance between phase accuracy and minimizing pre-ringing artifacts.

Practical Applications in Mixing and Mastering

When to Use Linear Phase EQ

Linear phase EQ shines in scenarios where phase coherence is critical. For example, when working with multi-mic’d sources, such as drum kits or stereo-mic’d pianos, maintaining the phase relationship between microphones can significantly affect the clarity and depth of the recording. It ensures that any frequency adjustments do not disrupt this delicate balance.

Another area where linear phase EQ excels is in complex mix elements that require precise tonal adjustments. This is particularly true for transient-heavy tracks, where traditional EQs might introduce unwanted artifacts that can muddy the sound.

Mixing Techniques

Incorporating linear phase EQ into your mixing and mastering workflow involves understanding its strengths and limitations. Here are some best practices:

• Phase Coherence: Use a linear phase EQ on stereo-correlated sources to maintain phase integrity. This is crucial for elements like overhead microphones for drums or stereo recordings of acoustic instruments.
• Transients: Apply it to transient-heavy tracks for clean, precise equalization without colorization. This helps smooth the natural attack and decay characteristics of the sound.
• Parallel Processing: When dealing with parallel tracks, it prevents phase issues that could arise from using different EQ curves on each track. phase cancellation that could arise from combining multiple processed signals. This ensures a cohesive and transparent mix.

Best Practices

To effectively incorporate linear phase EQ into your workflow:

1. Identify Critical Elements: Determine which elements in your mix would benefit most from phase-preserving equalization.
2. Balance Latency: Be mindful of the latency introduced by linear phase processing. Although it’s not suitable for live sound mixing, it works well in studio environments where latency can be managed.
3. Selective Use: Use linear phase EQ selectively rather than across all tracks to avoid unnecessary latency and potential pre-ringing artifacts.
4. A/B Testing: Regularly compare your processed track with and without linear phase EQ to ensure the changes are beneficial without introducing new issues.

Comparing Linear Phase and Minimum Phase Approaches

Linear phase EQ and minimum phase EQ (standard) operate on different principles, leading to distinct outcomes in audio processing. Understanding these differences is crucial for making informed decisions in your mixing and mastering projects.

Linear Phase EQ

• Phase Preservation: Maintains the phase relationship across all frequencies, ensuring that the original tonal balance remains intact.
• Latency: Introduces latency due to the need for signal delay, which can be managed in a digital audio workstation (DAW) but may not be suitable for live sound applications.
• Pre-Ringing: Can introduce pre-ringing artifacts, particularly noticeable during transient changes, which might affect the initial attack of sounds, especially with snare hits.

Minimum Phase EQ

• Phase Shifts: Alters the phase relationship between frequencies, potentially leading to a change in the perceived tonal quality of the audio. These phase changes essentially smear the sound.
• Low Latency: Generally has negligible latency, making it ideal for real-time applications such as live sound mixing.
• No Pre-Ringing: Does not exhibit pre-ringing artifacts, preserving the natural attack of transients.

Check out our list of our top 5 picks for the best EQ plugin.

Choosing the Right Type of EQ for Your Projects

Selecting the most suitable equalizer depends on your specific audio project requirements. Understanding the differences between each type can help you make an informed decision. Check out our chart below for recommended uses.

3 Popular Linear Phase EQ Plugins

The list below is of our favorite EQ plugins that support linear phase. Any of these would be a great addition to your plugin collection, producing precise, clean, and transparent sound.

1

FabFilter Pro Q-3

Check Price

2

Waves Linear Phase EQ

Check Price

3

Blue Cat Audio Liny EQ

Check Price

FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)

Final Thoughts

Understanding the nuances of linear phase equalization can enhances your mixing skills. By preserving the original phase relationships and reducing unwanted artifacts, linear phase EQ offers unparalleled precision in frequency manipulation. While it excels in transparency and corrective tasks, it’s essential to weigh its benefits against traditional minimum phase EQ methods, which might be preferable for certain creative applications. Ultimately, choosing the right type of EQ for your projects hinges on your specific needs and the complexity of your mix, ensuring optimal results whether you are engaged in mixing or mastering.

If you found this guide helpful, please consider subscribing to our blog for more music production tips, product reviews, and buying guides. Also, you can support new content by contributing to our tip jar.

“Some of the links within this article are affiliate links. These links are from various companies such as Amazon. This means if you click on any of these links and purchase the item or service, I will receive an affiliate commission. This is at no cost to you and the money gets invested back into Audio Sorcerer LLC.”